Top 5 Reasons To Buy Soy Candles Instead Of Regular Paraffin Candles

I agree soy candles are better. We offer 100 percent soy candles at a reasonable price. You can check them out at http://www.soylicious.com/stevenmasse

We can mail samples upon request.

The best price and quality soy candles, soaps, warmers, melts, etc. – http://www.soylicious.com/tbusch

As I check through the article, I realize the problem, you use soy promoters websites to make your case, this is like asking a Ford car dealer why Fords are the best cars, A VERY VERY BIASED OPINION IS WHAT YOU WILL GET. I would think a reporter would know better.

Total twaddle says I.

False, False, FALSE!!! You should do some more research before writing these articles. Lets address your points one by one, shall we?

1. “Soy candles are natural”

So is paraffin. Oil deposits are formed from the decaying remains of dead organic matter, and paraffin is refined from this. So yes, paraffin candles completely fit the bill for what people would consider “natural” (read: not synthetically made). Soy oil is only partially hydrogenated and must go through a chemical process using harsh and “unnatural” chemicals to get it to a point where it can be used for candle making purposes. Even at this point it is not technically a wax because it is still water soluble.

The claim that burning soy wax will not increase the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere is a FLAT OUT LIE! Anyone with a basic understanding of chemistry knows that any combustion reaction will create CO2 and H2O. You really betray you own illiteracy on this subject to make such a claim, suggesting that soy candles somehow defy the laws of physics.

You also mention that soy wax is biodegradable. But paraffin is also biodegradable so you really are not making the point that you think you are with that statement. I don’t think you’ve researched anything about paraffin.

2. “Soy candles burn 50% longer”

The burn time of a candle depends on several factors which include wax type, amount of fragrance, additives, type of wick and size of said wick. As a chandler (someone who makes candles for a living), I’ve used many different types of wax, including soy, for different applications and outcomes. I can tell you from my own thorough experimentation and documenting of burn times that soy does not burn 50% longer than paraffin. This is just another myth that is perpetuated by the soy wax manufacturers to sell their products.

There are many more paraffin wax blends on the market than there are soy blends, and not all paraffin blends burn at the same rate. There are some paraffin wax blends that burn faster than soy, this is true. However, there are also paraffin blends that burn at the same rate as soy. To simply say that soy wax burns longer than paraffin wax is a lazy assessment of the subject of burn time, and again, betrays your lack of knowledge.

3. “Soy candles burn cleaner”

Candle soot is the result of incomplete combustion at the flame and is a problem for ANY wax used, including soy. Again, like burn time, this is dependent an several variables. More fragrance will increase soot. A wick that that is too big for the candle will increase soot. Air currents will increase soot. From my experience, the type of wax used does not typically affect sooting. I have made paraffin candles that soot less than some soy candles that I’ve made. Sooting should be a concern for any chandler and much testing needs to be done to find a recipe that minimizes sooting.

The EPA has tested the claims that soy candles produce less soot and found that soy wax actually produces white soot that is not as visible as the black soot associated with traditional paraffin candles. It wouldn’t surprise me if soy candles actually sooted MORE than paraffin candles because soy candles typically require larger wicks than there paraffin counterparts which increases the amount of soot put of by them. The thing is, you would never know because you can’t see it. I think that this is where the misconception that soy burns cleaner comes from. The white soot is not any less of a health hazard, by the way. In any case, burning candles in your house is not any more dangerous than breathing the air outside, so this seems like scaremongering to me.

4. “Soy candles are non-toxic”

Again, so is paraffin. In fact, the FDA has approved paraffin for use in food, cosmetics and medicinal purposes. Paraffin is completely inert and can be eaten without any ill effects. Paraffin is a preservative and those shiny apples in the grocery store have been coated in paraffin for this purpose (apples are not naturally shiny). Paraffin is added to many chocolate products to give them a glossy and smooth appearance, and is used in canning to seal the jars. Vaseline is paraffin. In fact, many cosmetic products that are supposed to smooth and soften skin have paraffin in them. In addition, I would argue that paraffin wax is safer to burn than soy wax because some people can have severe allergic reactions to soy candles.

5. “The scent from soy candles is much stronger and more pleasant”

Agree to disagree. I can’t really say that you are wrong because scent is subjective, but I can say that you are in the minority with your opinion. Soy wax is notorious for having poor scent throw. Many chandlers (myself included) have experienced disappointment and frustration with soy wax being extremely finicky with regard to scent throw. Go onto any candle making forum and search “soy wax”. The overwhelming majority of posts related to soy wax will be people complaining that they have no scent throw. The veteran soy candlers will chime in with some advice but I’ve never seen an issue like this resolved before. Often times they will suggest adding things like crisco and coconut oil to them in the hopes that this will improve the scent throw. Almost anyone who makes soy candles will also tell you that you have to let them “cure” for at least 2 weeks before lighting them if you want to get a good throw, and that the longer you let them cure the better they will smell. If this doesn’t work then they tell you that the sent you are using just won’t work with soy and that you need to move on. Thats right, even people who make soy candles and presumably buy into this soy/health/eco nonsense admit that soy wax is difficult to work with and hard to get a good scent throw.

There are reasons that soy has poor scent throw and it has to do with the chemistry of the candle. I mentioned earlier that soy wax is not technically a wax because it is water soluble (this is in fact a selling point for soy wax manufacturers because they say that it makes clean up easier). By definition, wax is not water soluble. Guess what else is not water soluble – oils! The fragrance oils and essential oils used to scent candles are no different. Just like paraffin wax, they are not water soluble. What does this mean? It means that paraffin and fragrance oils are miscible (i.e. able to form a mixture with each other). This is why you don’t have problems with scent throw in paraffin wax. If scents were water based then they would work much better in soy and would probably work very poorly in paraffin. Historically, however, fragrance oils have been formulated to work paraffin because for a long time that was the only wax that was used (soy wax is relatively new). I’m not saying that it is impossible for soy wax to have as good a throw as paraffin but for this to happen you would need water based fragrances that have been formulated specifically for use in soy wax, and to my knowledge they don’t exist.

The poor scent throw is the main reason why people get frustrated and abandon soy. I also think this is why the soy wax manufacturers have made such an effort to deceive people into thinking that paraffin is dangerous, because they know that people won’t want a wax with poor scent throw. They can’t make their product better so they have to make other products look worse.

I also think it is disingenuous to suggest that soy wax is somehow more environmentally friendly because it is “renewable” plant. Soy fields don’t just pop up naturally. Forests clearing for agricultural purposes has become a huge environmental concern in and of itself. Harvesting soy crops year after year wreaks havoc on soils to the point where it becomes infertile and cannot support anymore growth. To combat this problem requires the production of millions of tons of fertilizer every single year, which is extremely energy intensive. What about the millions of gallons of water used to water the soy plants? How about the massive amounts of pesticides applied to the crops? Do you even care about the marine environment experiencing mass extinctions of species from agricultural runoff of these fertilizers and pesticides? Have you even thought about this?

Also, how do you think soy farmers harvest their crops? Not by hand, but with huge farming machinery that requires gasoline! Did you know that paraffin wax is a byproduct of oil refinement? People are not drilling oil for wax. THEY ARE DRILLING OIL TO MAKE SOY BEANS! Paraffin is waste from the agricultural industry. So instead of recycling this waste to make candles, you think we should just make more soy beans and create more waste? The hypocrisy of the green movement is glaring at times, your article is not exception.